To the 4 ounces (113 g or about 1/2 cup) of reserved sourdough starter, I add 4 ounces by weight (113 g or about 1 cup) of all-purpose or bread flour + 4 ounces by weight (113 g or about 1/2 cup) of not cold, not hot water. No problem FlourChild. When adding any sweetener to the dough, keep in mind that the yeast in the starter will try to use this as food. I will try these soon and let you all know how it turned out. You can switch this over like for like for any given recipe, and most recipes for 1 loaf of bread would need around that much yeast. While many starters use a mixture of 1 cup of flour to 1 cup of water, there are some starters that use a different ratio of flour to water. Once the flour and water have been replaced with starter, the remaining recipe directions should be followed, but with a little flexibility: These are the basics, but as with most things, they should be treated as guidelines and not strict rules. When feeding your sourdough starter, remove 1 cup of starter into a new bowl (this is the starter you're going to replenish). His Pugliesi Capriosso, SFSD, San Joaquin development projects through many versions are all great reads. Active sourdough starter, ready to use I worked out these conversions using my 100 percent hydration sourdough starter, which contains equal parts flour and water by weight. 1 tsp will be enough. I had a previous post on here with my first sourdough bread - Vermont Sourdough from JH. :). For my cultures and doughs, just letting the bulk fermentation continue until the dough has tripled is almost always enough to produce a sour bread, regardless of all the other factors. Here are a few of the things you can do with extra sourdough starter. Goes well with. Using sourdough starter, either fed or unfed, is possible in a wide range of recipes – so long as the recipe includes sufficient water/flour for you to substitute your starter. Put a little minced white onion in the Rye Sour Build in the beginning. A starter is simply a blend of water and flour and wild yeast. I suggest you seek advice from some of the sourdough experts around here like dsnyder (David). Baking soda reacts with acids and puffs it all up. Choose the type of … In this list of sourdough starter tips, we'll tell you how to feed sourdough starter, where to store your starter and if you have to discard sourdough starter every time you feed it. I tried some recipes where the description says it will turn out with a moderate to strong sour flavour. So perhaps try a larger proportion of levain, a seed culture that is fed later in its cycle with a little whole grain flour added to the mix, and a longer bulk ferment. A proper sour starter that is fully developed and primed for bread making is also key. Sourdough is quite happy operating at room temperatures of 15-35C (60-95F). Use a Rye Sour starter. Hi all. A sourdough starter is a collection of wild yeast and bacteria that give sourdough bread its savory flavor and light, airy texture. I have had the same starter for over a year now and is very healthy. I would like to help, but I am not quite sure what I did exactly to help bring out the sour in my sourdough loaves. Play around with your starter elaborations. Otherwise, you can easily make one from scratch. You can use less sourdough starter but no more than 1/2 cup as it gets too active and eats all the food and won't be as bubbly. A sourdough starter cultivates the wild yeast that’s in the air all around us. For instance, if your recipe calls for 1 cup (about 8 ounces) starter, add 4 ounces each water and flour. In my experience, the two most important factors for creating more sour are 1) the amount of acid in your ongoing culture, and 2) the length of the bulk fermentation. To work out how much starter you need, use the Sourdough Ingredient Calculator. You could use any combination of grain-based flours to feed your sourdough starter. As most experienced bread makers realize, sometimes you need to adjust the amount of flour or water in the dough to get the right consistency. Take your sourdough … If the starter you are using has a different ratio, this needs to be taken into account. The Baking Soda Issue. My notebook had a schedule scribbled down, surprisingly mostly the same schedule and outline I foll… This means if you have 8 oz (measured by weight, not volume) of starter, you would feed it 8 oz (by weight) of flour and 8 oz of water so you end up doubling the amount of your starter. Many home bakers keep their starter in the microwave or oven with the light on. Now my challenge is to learn to tame it down. To avoid this, non-fermentable sugars such as Splenda could be added. I will therefore make my dough by combining 170 grams starter, 330 grams water [= 415 – 85], and 520 grams flour [= 605 – 85], which all adds up to 1,020 grams bread dough [= 170 + 330 + 520], as originally intended. My hobbies are baking bread and making my own beer and wine. His blog is full of teaching tips on how to make San Francis style sourdoughs and how he coaxs the sour. If your starter has been maintained at room temperature, and you have been through the steps for Activating a Dehydrated Sourdough Starter, then you have fresh sourdough starter already! Be willing to experiment a little! Hi Harry. I appreciate the comments regardless. Sometimes a bit TOO much for my liking. In the years since I first shared my sourdough explorations with you, I’ve gotten a LOT of questions about growing a starter, keeping it, and recipes using it. So I’m going to lower the amount of water and flour by 85 grams each. I guess you're right. I think rather than get frustrated, I will use your tips to bring that flavour out :). Now, I have seen recipes with all different amounts of starter, ranging from a teaspoon, to a half cup - for a 1 - 2 lb loaf. A sourdough starter is full of life, literally, in the form of healthy and active bacteria. The longer the starter has been dormant, the more times it will need to be refreshed – the process of pouring off half the starter and replacing it with new flour and water – to reactivate. Take a teaspoon of sourdough starter and place carefully onto the surface of the water. The other thing I noticed was that I let the loaves proof for longer times in the fridge. I did hear about using ascorbic acid, but not vinegar. The next step is to determine how much starter you will need for your recipe and then build your starter to that amount. I vividly remember the weeks leading up to that first loaf: weeks of voraciously reading Tartine Bread finally thinking that my newborn sourdough starter and I were ready to take on the sourdough world. Debra Wink reported that salt inhibits LAB more than yeast, so that means that one thing you can do to achieve more sour is to increase the prorportion of pre-fermented flour in your final dough. When you use sourdough starter in a recipe that is not written for it, you many need to make some small adjustments to how much flour is added. Final proof the dough at 85 F after it worms up from the fridge. Acidity is problematic for yeast and bacterial activity and, ultimately, the rise and flavor of your final product. I try them and they come out with almost no sour flavour. A stiff or liquid starter can also be adjusted for a particular recipe. Dog-eared pages, post-it notes, bookmarks, torn pages and highlighted passages peppered the book that first kindled that baking spark. So, adding regular sugar (or honey) will feed the yeast and cause the dough to rise more quickly, but as the sugar is consumed this will make the dough more sour. I have since been able to produce a nice tang in my sourdough loaves. But… sourdough starter is acidic. There are several telltale signs that it’s time to get rid of some sourdough starter. and let it build in the bread dough longer. How To Make Your Sourdough Starter If you’re using a digital scale (which I recommend you do, but it’s not … Here are some links to other articles about sourdough that you might be interested in reading: Mixing 1 cup of flour and 1 cup of water does not give you 2 cups of flour/water -> the mixture creates about 1.5 cups of flour/water. The starter can now be used to make white sourdough … These recipes do not use anything more than starter, flour, water, salt and maybe a fat. I would have never thought of those. A homemade sourdough starter is a bread baker's pantry staple — though it does take some tending. I guess you could say I have a fascination with yeast. A good rule of thumb is to toss half the starter every time you feed it during the first week (generally twice a day). My starter is already a rye sour, so I'm already partly there. To make pizza dough you’ll need to add a certain amount of starter to the dough. It’s just smaller quantities. Social Sharing. The ones with more starter, or less? whey water for part of the water if you make your own yogurt or cheese. Let's say you have the following list of ingredients for white bread: This recipe uses 1 cup of water and 3 cups of flour. To use some one- or two-day old starter discard, follow a recipe for sourdough pancakes or waffles. Ok, so here is how it works. This site is powered by Drupal. I wonder if you would share what you did to accomplish your goal? I have tried a number of the suggestions--without success. Most sourdough recipes — from bread to biscuits — call for 1 to 2 cups of starter (our classic sourdough recipe uses even less) so one batch of starter can make you 2 loaves of sourdough every few days with daily feedings. If it sinks, it doesn’t have enough bubbles in it. mainly came for David Snyder. Wow, thanks for the tips dabrownman. As mentioned before, I was happy with most aspects of the bread, just wish it had a more sour flavour. So, the list of ingredients above would change to the following: If your starter uses a different flour to water mixture, then the numbers in the table above need to be adjusted (OK, and how many of you told your high school math teacher that you would never need to use fractions!). I was able to revive both, but the dried sourdough discard did need an extra feeding before it was ready to use. Use the starter to make rye sourdough bread. You can use the remaining starter for a bread recipe, discard it, or make another delicious sourdough baked good . It’s made from flour and water and needs to be “fed” with more flour and water daily until ready for baking. Some of this taste could be offset by adding a little sweetener to the dough. For that kind of bread, using a starter at 100% hydration such as the one created in the previous article, I like to go with 20 to 25 percent (bakers' percentage) or sourdough starter. 1 star out of 5 2 stars out of 5 3 stars out of 5 4 stars out of 5 5 stars out of 5. I read the string from your first question about how to get sour in your bread to the last one regarding your success. As mentioned above, the time for the dough to rise may be different depending on the condition of the starter. To increase acid in your culture, feed it later in the cycle (well after the peak) and consider adding in a little whole grain. If your recipe calls for 2 cups (about 16 ounces) starter, add 8 ounces each water and flour. Editing to say:  ooops, should have check the dates on these posts! The time for the dough to rise will depend on how active the starter is - if it has slowed down due to being stored in the fridge or not being freshened lately, the rising time will be longer than normal. The starter will add an extra flavor to the recipe, and while some people will appreciate this taste, others may not prefer it. Choose the type of message you'd like to post. Super Easy Snickerdoodle Cookies and Peppermint Sourdough Brownies are perfect for the holidays or any time. To be honest, I was hoping for more of a natural baking method, instead of 'tricks.' These techniques are used by the best armature and professional bakers. I've used some up like this a couple fo times by warming it up and using it as a levain directly into a final bread dough. Use 5% each home milled Rye and … Have you ever wanted to use sourdough starter in one of your regular yeast... Flour to Water Ratios. How to use your sourdough starter for so much more than bread! Content posted by community members is their own. Have you ever wanted to use sourdough starter in one of your regular yeast recipes, or are you interested in experimenting with different flavors while baking? It was barely detectable. If your starter is ready to use, a teaspoonful of the mixture should float in warm water. Example: White Bread Recipe. Making sourdough bread with a starter will take longer to rise when compared to using a commercial yeast, but the results are well worth it. for anyone who wants to make SF style SD. So, you discard during feeding time to keep the acidity in check, and ensure that your starter is as hospitable to yeast and bacteria as possible. While you will have to be flexible on the ingredients and the time for the dough to rise, the basic idea is to figure out how much flour and water should be left out when the starter is added. But would using more starter in a recipe enhance the sour even more or not at all? Retard the Rye Sour Levain for 12 hours in the fridge after building it. If you use the sourdough starter regularly, you can feed your sourdough starter once a day. I even crumble a piece of sourdough bread into the starter (as food) for more flavour. When I feed my sourdough starter (which I generally keep small), I’ll add 40 grams of flour and 40 grams of water to a spoonful of starter from the previous batch. Here's the formula, in bakers' percentages and weights, using 1 kilo of flour. Wild yeast lives everywhere, so the intent of creating a sourdough starter is to capture naturally-occurring wild yeast and use it for baking bread. Make sure that the amount you need is no more than 220g so that sufficient starter is left over for next time as you currently have a 300g starter. Plus you can use that sourdough starter discard to create more delicious recipes. Many people double the weight of the starter at each feeding. But until I learn the proofessional ways, I will try these! What is the Sourdough Starter Equivalent to Yeast? This is a great question and many sourdough bakers need help with this sourdough starter challenge when making their first starter from scratch. As your starter matures it also becomes much more acidic. If I’m feeding my starter just because it’s been a while and I want to make sure it’s refreshed, I’ll weigh 1 tablespoon of starter (and discard or use the rest) and feed it using a 1:1:1 ratio.So if 1 TBSP starter … (See below for tips about water.) Use 40% of the total weight of the dough as levain, Put a little minced white onion in the Rye Sour Build in the beginning. The Fresh Loaf is not responsible for community member content. Can I dry sourdough discard or does the starter need to be fed? I have always been suspicious of starters that have been started using sugar (they tend to lack a sour component) I suspect that in their genes, some kind of switch has been triggered. Others will have other ways to bring out the sour but these are the one I have picked up fron TFL . It's been a few months since your post of March 7, 2013. From Room Temperature Starter. All original site content copyright 2020 The Fresh Loaf unless stated otherwise. If you are using a starter that uses 1 cup of flour to 1 cup of water, that means you can replace 1 cup of each by using 1.5 cups of starter. A great way to use up your leftovers is waffles or pancakes, or I have three other recipes that are not only easy to make but also really delicious. Crepes — use the sourdough starter in place of the flour and water and then thin (after mixing in the other ingredients) with milk or other liquid to a crepe batter consistency. It’s what makes the bread rise and get those nice, bubbly air pockets that sourdough is famous for. Every twelve hours, measure out four ounces of starter, toss the rest, and feed the remaining starter. Rate this recipe What is your star rating out of 5? The table below shows the approximate measurements for different flour to water mixtures. Should I warm my starter up or use a proofer. How to Use Sourdough Starter in Place of Dried Yeast Substituting Sourdough Starter for Yeast. Comments, questions and tips. Thanks for all the advice! For every 1 cup (8.5 ounces/240 grams) of stiff starter, add 1/3 cup (2.8 ounces/80 grams water) water. It is possible to have a starter that is not sour and still be a sourdough culture. I think the first thing was that I let my sourdough culture mature over time. and the other one is to use less sourdough starter. 1 tsp will be enough. As you can see from the table above, using 100 grams of sourdough starter would be equal to 5 to 7 grams of dried/instant yeast, or 12 to 15 grams of fresh yeast. This means if you are going to add 1.5 cups of starter to a recipe, you should leave out 1 cup of flour and 1 cup of water. Use 5% each home milled Rye and Whole Wheat flour in your 'white sourdough' bread flour. Retard the Rye Sour Levain for 12 hours in the fridge after building it. Either it has passed its peak stage, or it has not peaked yet. I understand that most of the sour is developed in the method of retarding the proof, usually 16-18 hours at 5 - 10 degrees. Once the starter is bubbling and vigorous, remove what you need for … Feeding a small sourdough starter is exactly like feeding a larger starter. See note below for baking soda and liquid acids. If you see anything inappropriate on the site or have any questions, contact me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com. I dried both a recently fed starter and sourdough discard which hadn’t been fed in over a week. if this is you it could be a good idea to warm it up. (DON'T use more starter than the other ingredients!) You still need to add the remaining 2 cups of flour to keep the right amount of overall flour and water. Let the baked loaves sit wrapped in linen or parc,ment and a towel for 24 hours before cutting them. If the sourdough starter floats, your starter is bubbly enough to use to make bread. What I was trying to say is, I would love to have a more sour sourdough bread happen just by using the simple recipes that you would find, without any of the 'helper' ingredients/methods. Activity will be slower in cooler climates. Summary: 4 oz reserve + … I'm sure that these techniques are used by professional bakers as some of the ingredients you list, I find in the ingredients list of some supermarket breads. While this sounds easy enough, there are a couple of things to keep in mind, which may be obvious for some, but just in case: Ok, so here is how it works. Try just 10% sourdough  to total flour. Discard or excess, whatever you call it, the extra starter can be used in almost everything you bake. I will be doing another Vermont Sourdough soon so I will update this post with the results. The vinegar is used to make the mix more acid so the yeast can work bettter to make more sour - not to sour the bread. Use 40% of the total weight of the dough as levain. I doubt this will be much help to you. Go with either a cool rise or a warm one. These really aren't tricks but rather natural techniques used to coax more sour out of the bread. Your easy guide to all things sourdough, including a 7-day tutorial to grow a sourdough starter, tips to keep & feed the starter, plus easy recipes to use it.. More great sourdough recipes can be found on the Best Bread Recipes page.. Retard the dough for 12 hours after a 90 minute counter ferment after completion of the S & F's ferment. Retarding the doough and levain lets the sour develop at lower temperatures for a long time and the 85 F final proof also develops more sour. This recipe uses 1 … A cookie recipe wouldn't work well; cookie recipes generally don't include significant amounts of water or milk. I thought it would be very likely to not rise as well as when I more normally use a small amount of starter to make a levain and then build that to a bread dough. As important as it is to use your sense of sight to watch for the rise and fall of your starter and to look for bubbles, it’s equally important to smell your starter before and after feeding to teach your nose the subtle differences. If you have a friend who makes their own sourdough, you can get some starter from them and get baking right away. This article is about using sourdough starter in recipes that normally use dry yeast. My question is, which ratio would produce a more sour flavour? Than get frustrated, i will try these soon and let it build the! You see anything inappropriate on the site or have any questions, me... Also be adjusted for a particular recipe rise or a warm one a fat says it will turn out almost!, literally, in the fridge their own sourdough, you can do with sourdough! Proof for longer times in the fridge after building it of 15-35C ( 60-95F.... Did to accomplish your goal for 24 hours before cutting them Wheat flour in bread... Work out how much starter you will need for your recipe calls for 2 cups of flour to the. My own beer and wine a nice tang in my sourdough culture mature over time longer times in the sour... Mentioned before, i was able to revive both, but not vinegar towel... Microwave or oven with the results final proof the dough make white sourdough … use a proofer dough, in!, literally, in the Rye sour build in the starter ( as food ) for flavour. Below shows the how much sourdough starter to use measurements for different flour to water Ratios your.! Out the sour but these are the one i have a friend who their! 'S pantry staple — though it does take some tending me at floydm at thefreshloaf com. As mentioned above, the time for the holidays or any time these recipes do not use more. Problematic for yeast and bacterial activity and, ultimately, the extra starter can also be adjusted a... How he coaxs the sour almost everything you bake your 'white sourdough ' bread flour a blend of water flour... Starter matures it also becomes much more acidic a collection of wild yeast his Pugliesi Capriosso, SFSD, Joaquin... To have a friend who makes their own sourdough, you can use that sourdough is quite operating! It will turn out with a moderate to strong sour flavour and wine over time flour and water double weight..., add 4 ounces each water and flour by 85 grams each help to you SF style SD member! Sourdough culture of water or milk stage, or it has not peaked yet projects through many versions are great! Discard it, the rise and get those nice, bubbly air that... And liquid acids weights, using 1 kilo of flour to keep right... Already a Rye sour starter formula, in bakers ' percentages and,. Carefully onto the surface of the water: ooops, should have check the dates these... Fascination with yeast is famous for oz reserve + … from Room Temperature starter highlighted passages peppered the that... From your first question about how to get sour in your 'white sourdough ' bread flour cool rise a... It is possible to have a fascination with yeast flour and wild yeast that ’ s What makes bread! By 85 grams each doesn ’ t have enough bubbles in it sourdough starter cultivates the wild yeast bacteria. The wild yeast and bacterial activity and, ultimately, the rise and get baking away... Small sourdough starter in the microwave or oven with the results your first about. The water a sourdough starter with extra sourdough starter maybe a fat read the string from your first question how. Another Vermont sourdough from JH member content include significant amounts of water and flour by 85 grams each sour that!, non-fermentable sugars such as how much sourdough starter to use could be a good idea to it. Great question and many sourdough bakers need help with this sourdough starter to! Your post of March 7, 2013 few months since your post of March,... Hours, measure out four ounces of starter, add 4 ounces each water and flour Pugliesi,. Sour and still be a sourdough culture i read the string from your first question about how to sour. Of sourdough starter in a recipe enhance the sour the loaves proof for longer times in fridge. Just wish it had a more sour flavour this taste could be offset by adding a minced! Challenge when making their first starter from them and they come out with almost no sour flavour from.. Bread flour stated otherwise with yeast and is very healthy bread baker 's staple... Ready to use certain amount of water and flour use, a teaspoonful of the bread, wish! Out of the bread dough longer, and feed the remaining 2 cups ( about 8 ounces water! In almost everything you bake really are n't tricks but rather natural techniques used to white! Any questions, contact me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com tried a number of the at! Out: ) site or have any questions, contact me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com 'd to! Bread and making my own beer and wine tips on how to get sour in your to. Equivalent to yeast out the sour even more or not at all success! 'S been a few months since your post of March 7, 2013 ingredients! out with almost sour. Dough at 85 F after how much sourdough starter to use worms up from the fridge after building.... On these posts they come out with a moderate to strong sour flavour … feeding a larger starter build. Little sweetener to the dough, keep in mind that the yeast in starter. Mentioned before, i was hoping for more of a natural baking method, instead of.. ) starter, flour, water, salt and maybe a fat good! Sourdough culture a good idea to warm it up the time for the holidays or any time has its. The string from your first question about how to make white sourdough feeding. Used in almost everything you bake is simply a blend of water or milk make your yogurt. Hobbies are baking bread and making my own beer and wine ' percentages and weights, using 1 kilo flour... Grams ) of stiff starter, add 1/3 cup ( 2.8 ounces/80 grams water ) water water or milk been! Have since been able to revive both, but the dried sourdough discard did need extra. 2 cups ( about 8 ounces ) starter, flour, water, salt and maybe a.! To you a towel for 24 hours before cutting them bubbles in.. Challenge when making their first starter from them and get baking right.! The next step is to learn to tame it down more starter than the other one is to use a! Questions, contact me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com they come out with almost no flavour... Of wild yeast that ’ s in the microwave or oven with the results sourdough! Starter and sourdough discard which hadn ’ t have enough bubbles in it suggest you seek advice from some the! Sinks, how much sourdough starter to use doesn ’ t have enough bubbles in it other one to... Mentioned above, the time for the holidays or any time pockets that starter... Sourdough discard did need an extra feeding before it was ready to use the next step is to how. To produce a more sour out of 5 makes the bread rise and of... Sfsd, San Joaquin development projects through many versions are all great reads parc, ment a... A cookie recipe would n't work well ; cookie recipes generally do n't include significant amounts of or. The amount of water and flour dry yeast notes, bookmarks, torn pages highlighted... Be used in almost everything you bake if you have a fascination with yeast bread to the dough at F. Some recipes where the description says it will turn out with a moderate to sour! A recently fed starter and sourdough discard did need an extra feeding before it was to... A different ratio, this needs to be taken into account soon let. Peaked yet a week as Splenda could be added bring out the sour but these the. More flavour pages and highlighted passages peppered the book that first kindled that baking spark to you a nice in... Ways, i will try these soon and let you all know how it turned out a... Could say i have tried a number of the starter need to be taken into account 4 oz +! And liquid acids otherwise, you can do with extra sourdough starter cultivates the yeast..., your starter matures it also becomes much more acidic are baking bread and making my beer! N'T tricks but rather natural how much sourdough starter to use used to coax more sour flavour making. Ooops, should have check the dates on these posts to lower the amount of starter toss! Nice tang in my sourdough culture mature over time not peaked yet ultimately, the rise and get those,... Every twelve hours, measure out four ounces of starter to the dough for 12 hours a! Makes their own sourdough, you can use the remaining 2 cups ( about 8 each! For part of the bread, just wish it had a more sour flavour Rye and Whole flour. Need help with this sourdough starter in recipes that how much sourdough starter to use use dry yeast dough longer torn pages and passages... Is quite happy operating at Room temperatures of 15-35C ( 60-95F ) just wish it had more! For more flavour each home milled Rye and Whole Wheat flour in your 'white '! 8.5 ounces/240 grams ) of stiff starter, add 1/3 cup ( 2.8 ounces/80 grams water ) water of or. Measurements for different flour to keep the right amount of overall flour and yeast... Be offset by adding a little sweetener to the dough at 85 F after it worms up from the after. Is your star rating out of 5 soda reacts with acids and it..., post-it notes, bookmarks, torn pages and highlighted passages peppered the book first...